Comparison of Limit Load, Linear and Nonlinear FE Analyses of Stresses in a Large Nozzle-to-Shell Diameter Ratio Application

Michael A. Porter, Steven R. Massey, Dennis H. Martens
2004 Design and Analysis of Pressure Vessels, Heat Exchangers and Piping Components   unpublished
The analyses address a nominal 62-inch diameter nozzle in a nominal 124-inch diameter shell with a reinforcement pad. The nozzle is in a channel of a heat exchanger. This results in stiffening of the shell (adjacent to the nozzle) by the tube sheet and the channel head. The results of a WRC 297 analysis, linear elastic analysis, limit load analysis and plastic analysis are compared. The finite element analyses were accomplished utilizing commercial software and typical modeling techniques. As
more » ... ere is significant variance in the results derived with the different methodologies, the authors discuss the comparison of the results.
doi:10.1115/pvp2004-2598 fatcat:ww3yiv33pvdqnjvhddn4qrk5dq