Automatic identification of bird females using egg phenotype [article]

Michal Sulc, Anna E. Hughes, Jolyon Troscianko, Gabriela Stetkova, Petr Prochazka, MIlica Pozgayova, Lubomir Pialek, Radka Pialkova, Vojtech Brlik, Marcel Honza
2020 bioRxiv   pre-print
1. Identification of individuals greatly contributes to understanding animal ecology and evolution, and in many cases can only be achieved using expensive and invasive techniques. Advances in computing technology offer alternative cost-effective techniques which are less invasive and can discriminate between individuals based on visual and/or acoustic cues. Here, we employ human assessment and an automatic analytical approach to predict the identity of common cuckoo (Cuculus canorus) females
more » ... ed on the appearance of their eggs. The cuckoos secretive brood parasitic strategy makes studying its life history very challenging. Eggs were analysed using calibrated digital photography for quantifying spotting pattern, size and shape, and spectrometry for measuring colour. Cuckoo females were identified from genetic sampling of their nestlings, allowing us to determine the accuracy of human and automatic female assignment. Finally, we used a novel same-different approach that uses both genetic and phenotypic information to assign eggs that were not genetically analysed. 2. Our results supported the constant egg-type hypothesis, showing that individual cuckoo females lay eggs with a relatively constant appearance and that eggs laid by different females differ more than eggs laid by the same female. The accuracy of unsupervised hierarchical clustering was comparable to assessments of experienced human observers. Supervised random forest analysis showed better results, with higher cluster accuracy. Same-different analysis was able to assign 22 of 87 unidentified cuckoo eggs to seven already known females. 3. Our study showed that egg appearance on its own is not sufficient for identification of individual cuckoo females. We therefore advocate genetic analysis to be used for this purpose. However, supervised analytical methods reliably assigned a relatively high number of eggs without genetic data to their mothers which can be used in conjunction with genetic testing as a cost-effective method for increasing sample sizes for eggs where genetic samples could not be obtained.
doi:10.1101/2020.11.25.398131 fatcat:kzl7rfna5ffk3j2i3iepl6prda