生命科学研究における成果発表の意義とその規制の許容性についての一考察 : 2011~2012年H5N1型インフルエンザウイルス研究論文問題を題材として
Study of the publication meaning of life scientific research result and the acceptability of its restriction : learning from the publication issues of the 2011-2012 Influenza H5N1 Virus papers

Ayako KAMISATO
2013 Bioethics  
in the first half of 2012 , two research papers on the transmission of influenza HsNl virus among ferrets were published in Nature and Science . Prior to their publication, the U , S. Depart − ment Qf Health and Hurnan Services recommended deletion of the methodological deta「 ls of the experiments from the papers , and this Ied to heated debate. While the papers were e )entualIy fulIy published , it is nQted that during the publication debate , the publlcation meanlng and value of the Iife
more » ... ue of the Iife science research resu [ t were not dlscussed . This paper first Iooked back on the debate and made clear about the problems included , then 「 t expands on the observation that " freedom of sci − entific research " , " freedom of expression " , " responsibility of scientlsts " and " meaning of I「 fe sci − ence research " are inherent in the publication of Iife science research results , The paper con − cludes that restriction of publication on 巨fe science research results can only be permltted when the need of restriction overwhelm the meaning and value of the pubIication, 生 命 倫理 VOL . 23 NO . 12013 . 9105 N 工 工 一 Electronic Library
doi:10.20593/jabedit.23.1_105 fatcat:kstvzx2sqvc4npb6i2pqz27iui