Author response: Rapid transgenerational adaptation in response to intercropping reduces competition [peer_review]

Laura Stefan, Nadine Engbersen, Christian Schöb
2022 unpublished
By capitalising on positive biodiversity-productivity relationships, intercropping provides opportunities to improve agricultural sustainability. Intercropping is generally implemented using commercial seeds that were bred for maximal productivity in monocultures, thereby ignoring the ability of plants to adapt over generations to the surrounding neighbourhood, notably through increased complementarity, that is reduced competition or increased facilitation. This is why using monoculture-adapted
more » ... seeds for intercropping might limit the benefits of crop diversity on yield. However, the adaptation potential of crops and the corresponding changes in complementarity have not been explored in annual crop systems. Here we show that plant-plant interactions among annual crops shifted towards reduced competition and/or increased facilitation when the plants were growing in the same community type as their parents did in the previous two generations. Total yield did not respond to this common coexistence history, but in fertilized conditions, we observed increased overyielding in mixtures with a common coexistence history. Surprisingly, we observed character convergence between species sharing the same coexistence history for two generations, in monocultures but also in mixtures: the six crop species tested converged towards taller phenotypes with lower leaf dry matter content. This study provides the first empirical evidence for the potential of parental diversity affecting plant-plant interactions, species complementarity and therefore potentially ecosystem functioning of the following generations in annual cropping systems. Although further studies are required to assess the context-dependence of these results, our findings may still have important implications for diversified agriculture as they illustrate the potential of targeted cultivars to increase complementarity of species in intercropping, which could be achieved through specific breeding for mixtures. Editor's evaluation This study reports that interactions between crop species grown over three generations in mixture instead of monoculture become less competitive/more facilitative, suggesting a way to breed for increased mixture yield. This fundamental finding is of high interest to the fields of ecology and agriculture, as well as society seeking new solutions to satisfy increasing food demands. The methodological approach is compelling, yet distinguishing between reduced competition and increased facilitation remains challenging.
doi:10.7554/elife.77577.sa2 fatcat:mgub5ozkjbgrtelec2lwxbheka