Impact of URI Canonicalization on Memento Count

Mat Kelly, Lulwah M. Alkwai, Sawood Alam, Herbert Van de Sompel, Michael L. Nelson, Michele C. Weigle
2017 2017 ACM/IEEE Joint Conference on Digital Libraries (JCDL)  
Quantifying the captures of a URI over time is useful for researchers to identify the extent to which a Web page has been archived. Memento TimeMaps provide a format to list mementos (URI-Ms) for captures along with brief metadata, like Memento-Datetime, for each URI-M. However, when some URI-Ms are dereferenced, they simply provide a redirect to a different URI-M (instead of a unique representation at the datetime), often also present in the TimeMap. This infers that confidently obtaining an
more » ... ntly obtaining an accurate count quantifying the number of non-forwarding captures for a URI-R is not possible using a TimeMap alone and that the magnitude of a TimeMap is not equivalent to the number of representations it identifies. In this work we discuss this particular phenomena in depth. We also perform a breakdown of the dynamics of counting mementos for a particular URI-R ( and quantify the prevalence of the various canonicalization patterns that exacerbate attempts at counting using only a TimeMap. For we found that 84.9% of the URI-Ms result in an HTTP redirect when dereferenced. We expand on and apply this metric to TimeMaps for seven other URI-Rs of large Web sites and thirteen academic institutions. Using a ratio metric DI for the number of URI-Ms without redirects to those requiring a redirect when dereferenced, five of the eight large web sites' and two of the thirteen academic institutions' TimeMaps had a ratio of ratio less than one, indicating that more than half of the URI-Ms in these TimeMaps result in redirects when dereferenced.
doi:10.1109/jcdl.2017.7991601 dblp:conf/jcdl/KellyAASNW17 fatcat:xaq3dvxzgzgmri27pgmub4ikdy