To Have and To Hold: What Does Love (of Money) Have to do with Joint Tax Filing?

Stephanie Hunter McMahon
2009 Social Science Research Network  
Wealthy taxpayers have always attempted to reduce their federal income taxes. Before 1948, when the United States had an individual-based system, one popular method was to shift income between spouses so that more of a husband's income could be reported by and taxed to his lower-income, and thus lower-tax-bracket, wife. Congress eliminated the reward for this tax-avoidance behavior in 1948 by nationalizing income splitting via the joint return. Today, there are proposals to return to an
more » ... al-based system. Evaluating the proposal for individual filing, this Article first explores the development of the income-splitting joint return as a historical guide to the potential costs of this proposal. The Article then rejects the prospect that today's Internal Revenue Service (IRS) will be able to rein in a resurgence of this type of tax avoidance. Finally, in addition to these practical concerns, this Article contends that calculations on a unitary basis remain today, as in the past, more accurate and more just for judging a married couple's ability to pay taxes when compared to other taxpayers. As a result of these considerations, the joint return is the more equitable method of marital tax filing. * I would like to thank
doi:10.2139/ssrn.1344431 fatcat:r4d7altmjnhptmldg75tkboksa