Why the Dalai Lama Should Read Aristotle

Stephen Mccarthy, Candidate
2001 Journal of Buddhist Ethics   unpublished
The purpose of this paper is to discover a classical foundation for the establishment of universal human rights in Buddhism. Such a foundation must necessarily overcome the modern barrier imposed by the Asian values rhetoric and its claims that "Western," Lockean, and essentially private ideas of rights have no place in Asian "family-oriented" culture. To facilitate its purpose, this paper will consider the modern, Lockean understanding of "rights" as the source of much of the Asian values'
more » ... ment, and proceed to an examination into the compatibility of a Buddhist understanding of human rights with Aristotle's understanding of ethics and natural law. If it is possible to discover the source of universal human rights in Aristotle's writings, as well as discover a compatibility to Buddhist beliefs and practices, then we may ground a case for the idea of human rights existing prior to their modern Lockean origins and accessible to Buddhism. Recently some Asian governments have contended that the standards of human rights laid down in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights are those advocated by the West and cannot be applied to Asia and other parts of the Third World because of differences in culture and differences in social and economic development. I do not share this view and I am convinced that the majority of Asian people do not support this view either, for it is the inherent nature of all human beings to yearn for freedom, equality, and dignity .