Comment on wcd-2021-19 [peer_review]

2021 unpublished
The Saharan Heat Low (SHL) is a key component of the West African monsoon system at synoptic scale and a driver of summertime precipitation over the Sahel region. Therefore, accurate seasonal precipitation forecasts rely in part on a proper representation of the SHL characteristics in seasonal forecasts models. This is investigated using the last versions of two seasonal forecast systems namely the SEAS5 and MF7 systems respectively from the European Center of Medium range 5 Weather Forecasts
more » ... Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) and Meteo-France. The SHL characteristics in the seasonal forecast models is assessed based on a comparison with the fifth ECMWF ReAnalysis (ERA5) for the period 1993-2016. The analysis of the modes of variability shows that the seasonal forecast models have issues with the timing of the SHL pulsations and the intensities when compared to ERA5. SEAS5 and MF7 show a cooling trend centered on the Sahara and a warming trend located in the eastern part of the Sahara, respectively. Both models tend to under-estimate the inter-annual variability of the SHL. We also show that the 10 seasonal forecast models detect the eastward and westward shift of the SHL during the monsoon season. The use of statistical bias correction methods significantly reduces the bias in the seasonal forecast models and improves the forecast score. Despite an improvement of prediction score, the SHL-related forecast skills of SEAS5 and MF7 remain weak for a lead time beyond 1 month.
doi:10.5194/wcd-2021-19-rc1 fatcat:4jgvifdjtngm7kg6ccbfdodet4