Depression, psychological stress, vascular dysfunction, and cardiovascular disease: thinking outside the barrel
Julian H. Lombard
2010
Journal of applied physiology
THE STRESS RESPONSE is present not only in humans and other mammals but also in more primitive species such as fish (5). It is often said that the accomplishment of some tasks is "easier than shooting fish in a barrel." However, the potential outcomes of this scenario are not so optimistic from the viewpoint of the fish. In humans, psychological stress, hopelessness, and depression can be risk factors for disastrous cardiovascular events such as stroke, coronary ischemia, and myocardial
more »
... on (8). These conditions can be silent killers, as evidenced by cases where extremely fit individuals without known risk factors suffer sudden catastrophic events such as heart attacks under conditions of sustained stress, either external or self-imposed. The study by d'Audiffret and coworkers in this issue of the Journal of Applied Physiology (2) employs a variety of cardiovascular measurements in a comprehensive study to identify specific vascular changes occurring in an established rodent model of stress and depressive behaviorthe unpredictable chronic mild stress (UCMS) model. Using this approach, the authors seek to gain insight into an extremely complex problem, namely how do conditions of psychological stress and/or depression lead to the vascular dysfunction widely reported in human depression? It is well known that psychological stress and depression are associated with cardiovascular disease (1, 4 -6). However, the relationship between stress and/or depression and cardiovascular disease defies easy analysis because there is also good evidence that the presence of cardiovascular disease itself can lead to depression (4). These complex relationships raise three possibilities: 1) depression is a risk factor for cardiovascular disease; 2) cardiovascular disease is a risk factor for depression; or 3) a common underlying pathology related to the effects of chronic stress manifests itself both as depression and as cardiovascular disease, leading to the familiar association between these conditions (4). Superimposed on these complex relationships are potential genetic risk factors and a wide array of societal stressors, including socioeconomic status, employment situations, and interpersonal relationships that can lead to physiological changes favoring the development of vascular dysfunction (1, 5). Psychological stress can contribute to a number of pathological changes in the vasculature, including intimal-medial thickening (12) and atherosclerotic changes in the blood vessels (1, 11, 12). Controlled mental stress tests have been widely used to identify vascular dysfunction and to gain insight into the factors leading to the development of vascular diseases such as hypertension and atherosclerosis in humans. These approaches have shown that even a brief exposure to mental stress can lead to a fairly sustained reduction in endothelium-dependent vasodilation in humans (3, 7, 9) . In women, intimalmedial thickening and subclinical atherosclerosis have been reported to have a significant association with indexes of hopelessness, independent of other factors such as age, race, income, depressive symptoms, and known risk factors for cardiovascular disease (12). Other studies have shown that indicators of endothelial dysfunction are present and associated with anxiety and depression in patients with posttraumatic stress disorder (11) and in cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicularis) subjected to social stress (10, 13). Studies in monkeys indicate that deficits in endothelial function are closely related to recent stress exposure and do not persist after stressful conditions have been removed (13). Other reports suggest that yoga and meditation to relieve stress lead to improved endothelial function in patients with coronary artery disease (8). Overall, these findings and others indicate that stress and depression can have a dramatic negative impact on vascular function, but vascular dysfunction in these conditions is amenable to therapeutic approaches that reduce stress and depression. Despite the extensive evidence linking stress and depression with impaired cardiovascular function, the underlying mechanisms for the association between stress, depression, and cardiovascular disease are difficult to decipher. The potential physiological links between stress, depression, and cardiovascular disease are multiple and extremely complex. These include the sympathetic nervous system (1, 5, 10), neuropeptides (1), inflammatory cytokines (1, 5, 11), endothelin-1 (9), oxidant stress and free radical formation (1, 5), humoral factors, (1, 5, 6, 11) , elevated homocysteine (1), and dyslipidemia (1) , all of which can potentially contribute to altered vascular function, especially reduced endothelium-dependent vasodilatation, which is an important predictor of adverse cardiovascular events in humans. A major strength of the study by d'Audiffret and coworkers (2) is its novelty, because two disciplines (behavioral sciences and cardiovascular research) team up to evaluate vascular alterations in an established rodent model of stress and depression. The investigators perform a comprehensive evaluation of multiple parameters of vascular function and couple these measurements with an extensive quantitative documentation of depressive behavior in the animals following the stress protocol. Consistent with studies of psychological stress and depression in humans (3, 7, 9) , the investigators demonstrate that endothelium-dependent vasodilatation is compromised in aortas of mice subjected to UCMS. The authors also demonstrate that methacholine leads to a large increase in NO release with little H 2 O 2 release in aortas of control mice while the same agonist causes a substantial H 2 O 2 release coupled with a severely reduced NO release in aortas of UCMS mice. Consistent with these observations, L-NAME nearly abolishes methacholine-induced dilation in arteries of control mice
doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00203.2010
pmid:20203070
fatcat:idio34hdaze77mjig76f3hefny