On the precision of social and information networks
Proceedings of the first ACM conference on Online social networks - COSN '13
The di↵usion of information on online social and information networks has been a popular topic of study in recent years, but attention has typically focused on speed of dissemination and recall (i.e. the fraction of users getting a piece of information). In this paper, we study the complementary notion of the precision of information di↵usion. Our model of information dissemination is "broadcast-based", i.e., one where every message (original or forwarded) from a user goes to a fixed set of
... a fixed set of recipients, often called the user's "friends" or "followers", as in Facebook and Twitter. The precision of the di↵usion process is then defined as the fraction of received messages that a user finds interesting. On first glance, it seems that broadcast-based information di↵usion is a "blunt" targeting mechanism, and must necessarily su↵er from low precision. Somewhat surprisingly, we present preliminary experimental and analytical evidence to the contrary: it is possible to simultaneously have high precision (i.e. is bounded below by a constant), high recall, and low diameter! We start by presenting a set of conditions on the structure of user interests, and analytically show the necessity of each of these conditions for obtaining high precision. We also present preliminary experimental evidence from Twitter verifying that these conditions are satisfied. We then prove that the Kronecker-graph based generative model of Leskovec et al. satisfies these conditions given an appropriate and natural definition of user interests. Further, we show that this model also has high precision, high recall, and low diameter. We finally present preliminary experimental evidence showing Twitter has high precision, validating our conclusion. This is perhaps a first step towards a formal understanding of the immense popularity of online social networks as an information dissemination mechanism.