Comprehending 3D and 4D ontology-driven conceptual models: An empirical study

Michaël Verdonck, Frederik Gailly, Sergio de Cesare
2020 Information Systems  
This paper presents an empirical study that investigates the extent to which the pragmatic quality of ontology-driven models is influenced by the choice of a particular ontology, given a certain understanding of that ontology. To this end, we analyzed previous research efforts and distilled three hypotheses based on different metaphysical characteristics. An experiment based on two foundational ontologies (UFO and BORO) involving 158 participants was then carried out, followed by a protocol
more » ... ysis to gain further insights into the results of experiment. We then extracted five derivations from the results of the empirical study in order to summarize our findings. Overall, the results confirm that the choice of a foundational ontology can lead to significant differences in the interpretation and comprehension of the conceptual models produced. Moreover, the effect of applying a certain foundational ontology can cause considerable variations in the effort required to comprehend these models.
doi:10.1016/j.is.2020.101568 fatcat:bkinnva4rjbcpjfdlvo5qhdacu