On transitional space, unresolved conflicts, and an uncertain teacher education

Donna Kalmbach Phillips
2010 Teachers and Teaching: theory and practice  
Description This research project began as an effort to redesign a learning theory course as transitional space and evolved into an analysis of how unresolved conflict from younger learning selves influence graduate preservice teachers' acquisition of teacher identity. The study draws upon work by Ellsworth (2005) on transitional space and Britzman (2007) on "Teacher Education as Uneven Development. " The data for the study were collected throughout a three-semester graduate teacher education
more » ... ogram and include narrative and formal writing using theoretical discourses. Foucauldian concepts of discourse analysis were used to interpret the initial data set; discourse analysis maps were then employed to further develop data interpretation. Two case study illustrations of preservice teachers resulted from this work. These demonstrate how transitional space is troubled space and the unevenness of teacher development. The study raises the question, "What will teacher education do with uncertainty?" Keywords teacher development, teacher identity, subjectivity, discourse Disciplines Education Comments This document has undergone peer review. This is an electronic version of an article published in: This document has undergone peer review. This is an electronic version of an article published in: Phillips, D. K. (2010). On transitional space, unresolved conflicts, and an uncertain teacher education. This research project began as an effort to redesign a learning theory course as transitional space and evolved into an analysis of how unresolved conflict from younger learning selves influence graduate preservice teachers' acquisition of teacher identity. The study draws upon work by Ellsworth (2005) on transitional space and Britzman (2007) on "Teacher Education as Uneven Development." The data for the study were collected throughout a three-semester graduate teacher education program and include narrative and formal writing using theoretical discourses. Foucauldian concepts of discourse analysis were used to interpret the initial data set; discourse analysis maps were then employed to further develop data interpretation. Two case study illustrations of preservice teachers resulted from this work. These demonstrate how transitional space is troubled space and the unevenness of teacher development. The study raises the question, "What will teacher education do with uncertainty?"
doi:10.1080/13540602.2010.507970 fatcat:rqmhjcyb2rh4rmfgypxnco2zje