The politics of ideas: The complex interplay of health inequalities research and policy

K. E. Smith
2013 Science and Public Policy  
Word count (abstract): 150 Word count (main text, including references but excluding abstract and title page): 10,934 Abstract Public health research is overtly orientated towards influencing policy and yet, despite official commitments to 'evidence-based policy', most analyses conclude the impact of public health research has been limited. Based on an analysis of post-1997 UK policy statements and interviews with 112 key actors, this article argues that the failure of 'evidence-based' policy
more » ... nce-based' policy to emerge relates to the fact it is ideas, not evidence, which travel between research and policy, and that these malleable entities are translated as they move between actors. By unpacking six factors that appear to have shaped the 'interplay of ideas' about health inequalities, the article draws attention to the ways in which policy influences research (as well as the other way round). The conclusion argues two distinct 'idea types' are evident within the data, each of which helps explain the difficulties in achieving 'evidence-based' policy responses to health inequalities: 'institutionalised ideas' and 'chameleonic ideas'.
doi:10.1093/scipol/sct085 fatcat:fgobyd6ibfasfdwjb7olwtinje