Black Girls, White Girls, American Girls: Slavery and Racialized Perspectives in Abolitionist and Neoabolitionist Children's Literature
Brigitte Fielder
2017
Tulsa Studies in Women's Literature
Analyzing abolitionist and neoabolitionist girlhood stories of racial pairing from the nineteenth and twenty-first centuries, this essay shows how children's literature about interracial friendship represents differently racialized experiences of and responses to slavery. The article presents fiction by women writers such as Harriet Beecher Stowe and Lydia Maria Child alongside Sarah Masters Buckey and Denise Lewis Patrick's American Girl historical fiction series about Cécile and Marie-Grace
more »
... order to show how such literature stages free children's relationships to slavery through their own racialization. While nineteenth-century abolitionist children's literature models how to present slavery and racism to free, white children, the American Girl series extends this model to consider how African American children's literature considers black child readers and black children's specialized knowledge about racism. The model of narration and scripting of reading practices in the Cécile and Marie-Grace stories promote cross-racial identification, showing how, because children read from already racialized perspectives that literature also informs, both black and white children might benefit from seeing alternating perspectives of slavery represented. By further re-thinking the boundaries of who might identify with other enslaved or enslavable child characters, we might unveil more radical antiracist potential in this children's literature. In Harriet Beecher Stowe's 1852 novel Uncle Tom's Cabin; or, Life Among the Lowly, the white Eva St. Clare insists on hearing about the violence enacted upon Prue, a woman enslaved on a nearby plantation, and her subsequent death. Eva asks, "And why shouldn't I hear it? It an't so much for me to hear it, as for poor Prue to suffer it." 1 The ultimate effect of slavery on this young abolitionist is her own death. In sentimental abolitionist literature, even a white girl can, essentially, die of slavery. This scene raises questions of how stories about slavery are told to children and about the implications of slavery for free children. The debate over whether or not Eva should learn what happened to Prue is an antecedent to present-day discussions about whether white children's "innocence" should be risked in exchange for their learning about the existence of racism and racial violence. 2 Such conversations ignore that black children and their
doi:10.1353/tsw.2017.0025
fatcat:3sghgz75rbdknfdyqig256k7km