MICHAEL I. BROWN. Redeeming REDD: Policies, Incentives and Social Feasibility for Avoided Deforestation. London: Routledge and New York: Earthscan, 2013, xii+330p

de Jong Wil
2014 Southeast Asian studies  
Book Reviews 225 the changes connected to its proximity to Ho Chi Minh City. It is somewhat short on analysis of whether or not the Hóc Môn community exerted any significant influence on the city. Another point that perhaps deserves a clearer explanation or deeper exploration and is somewhat interconnected with the above observation lies in the very title of the book Saigon's Edge: On the Margins of Ho Chi Minh City. Given that the author mainly relates the situation in Hóc Môn during the
more » ... ôn during the modern period dwelling very little on the "Saigon period" and that the book is largely based on synchronic anthropological research rather than historical investigation, what role does the shift from "Saigon" to "Ho Chi Minh City" play in his analysis and in the title of the book? Harms states that he has "attempted to use the tools of a native discourse in order to unravel that discourse and show what it reveals, what it masks, and also what it does" (p. 238). However, it is hard to imagine that those same people living on the fringes he described with palpable sympathy using the tools of a native discourse would be able to fully or even partially grasp this study created in a highly academic and urban theoretical register, both in concept and in vocabulary. Thus, Harms' warm a nd, in my opinion, poetic study of Hóc Môn cannot be heard by the people of Hóc Môn or of any other outer-cities for that matter, but it will resound among specialists of Vietnam and cultural anthropology and sociology to whom it will be very useful.
doi:10.20495/seas.3.1_225 fatcat:gxlzsrbr6rff3lkwwbayhiiyei