Naive probability: A mental model theory of extensional reasoning

P. N. Johnson-Laird, Paolo Legrenzi, Vittorio Girotto, Maria Sonino Legrenzi, Jean-Paul Caverni
1999 Psychological review  
This article outlines a theory of naive probability. According to the theory, individuals who are unfamiliar with the probability calculus can infer the probabilities of events in an extensional way: They construct mental models of what is true in the various possibilities. Each model represents an equiprobable alternative unless individuals have beliefs to the contrary, in which case some models will have higher probabilities than others. The probability of an event depends on the proportion
more » ... models in which it occurs. The theory predicts several phenomena of reasoning about absolute probabilities, including typical biases. It correctly predicts certain cognitive illusions in inferences about relative probabilities. It accommodates reasoning based on numerical premises, and it explains how naive reasoners can infer posterior probabilities without relying on Bayes's theorem. Finally, it dispels some common misconceptions of probabilistic reasoning.
doi:10.1037//0033-295x.106.1.62 fatcat:vwjg7opguzcr7pfoziwkmvxviy