In 2014, Birtch et al. published an article that, in our view, contained unnecessary negative cultural/racial stereotyping in a vignette presented in their introduction. Given the potentially harmful consequences of negative stereotyping, and the relatively frequent use of vignettes in the business ethics literature, this prompted us to wonder whether this was an isolated instance or a more widespread occurrence. To investigate this question, we conducted a search of the scholarly literature

more »

... articles containing the string 'vignette' or 'scenario', and 'business ethics' using the EBSCOhost databases to which our institution subscribes. This search yielded a collection of 154 articles where vignettes were presented. Of these, approximately 18% contained negative cultural or racial stereotyping while 38% contained some form of negative gender stereotyping. In our view, these are uncomfortably high frequencies, so uncomfortably high, in fact, that they prompt us to conclude with a plea to authors, editors and reviewers within the business ethics academic literature to be on guard against this practice.